Why Your Nonprofit Should Take a Strategic Approach to AI Tools – Sooner Rather Than Later
Many nonprofit leaders are taking a cautious approach to Artificial Intelligence (AI), preferring to wait and see how the technology evolves before making a significant investment. This risk-averse stance is understandable, but it has created a new challenge: while leadership is waiting, staff members are already experimenting with AI on their own, often using free, public tools to boost their productivity. This individual experimentation, while well-intentioned, is leading to a fragmented and high-risk IT environment. Using free AI tools at Nonprofits isn’t a winning formula. Instead of waiting for the perfect solution to emerge, it’s time for leadership to put AI on the strategic agenda. Survey staff on what tools they are already using and enlist those early adopters to help develop a plan.
This strategic shift is necessary because while the allure of “free” is powerful, it’s a path fraught with risk. At Community IT Innovators, our work with nonprofits has shown us that what seems like a simple, no-cost solution can actually create significant—and costly—vulnerabilities. To truly harness the power of AI, a strategic shift is needed. The smartest move for your nonprofit is not to dabble in free, public tools, but to invest in a few carefully selected enterprise-level platforms and train your team to use them wisely.
Starting with What You Already Have
While it’s important to be strategic about new AI investments, most nonprofits already have an enterprise-level AI tool at their fingertips without realizing it. The two main work platforms for nonprofits—Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace—are now incorporating powerful AI capabilities directly into their core applications.
If your organization uses one of these platforms, you probably already have access to tools that can draft emails in Outlook or Gmail, summarize documents in Word or Docs, and create presentations in PowerPoint or Slides. Instead of struggling to consolidate staff around new tools, consider starting your AI journey by training your team on the platforms they use every day. This approach offers a familiar environment for learning and the built-in security of your existing work platform.
The Hidden Costs of “Free” AI: Data Privacy and Security
The most significant risk with free AI tools is data privacy. When your staff uses a public AI model, the information they input—whether it’s a draft grant proposal, confidential donor notes, or internal meeting summaries—is not truly private. The privacy policies of these companies often state that the data you provide can be used to train and improve their models.
Consider the potential for a data breach. A well-meaning employee might upload a list of donor names and contact information to generate a personalized appeal. Or a program manager might use a public tool to summarize a confidential meeting about a sensitive case. This “shadow IT” use of unapproved software creates a serious exposure. Your nonprofit could be inadvertently sharing private information with a third-party company, a practice that can violate your own internal policies, compromise donor trust, and expose your organization to legal and financial risk.
Investing in a vetted, paid AI tool—and managing it under an administrator—provides a crucial layer of security. An enterprise license for a tool like Microsoft Copilot or Google Workplace Gemini, for example, comes with specific privacy guarantees. The data you input is managed within your organization’s secure tenant and is not used to train the public AI model. An administrator can monitor usage, enforce compliance, and ensure that your organization’s sensitive data is never exposed. This proactive approach to data governance is essential for maintaining trust with your donors and the communities you serve. Using free AI tools at your nonprofit may not be what you think – you may just have to learn more about the tools you have for “free” with the licenses you already have.
Consolidating for Efficiency and Risk Mitigation
The AI landscape is expanding at an astonishing pace. Every week, it seems a new tool promises to revolutionize a specific task, from content creation to meeting transcription. Allowing staff to use dozens of different tools may seem like empowering them, but it leads to a fragmented and chaotic IT environment.
This lack of consolidation creates multiple problems:
- Training Overload: It’s impossible to provide comprehensive training for every free tool available. By standardizing on a small number of approved, paid tools, your organization can invest in robust training and professional development. This ensures that staff not only know how to use the tools but understand the ethical and security best practices that come with them.
- Inconsistent Workflows: A patchwork of different AI tools can lead to inconsistent quality and disorganized data. Consolidating around a single tool or a small suite of tools—like a unified platform for project management, a dedicated note-taking AI, and an enterprise-level content generator—creates a more cohesive and efficient workflow.
- Cost Inefficiency: While individual staff members might pay for separate “pro” licenses, these costs can add up quickly. A managed service provider can help you negotiate enterprise-level licenses that are significantly more cost-effective for your entire team. You can get more for your money while gaining the security and administrative oversight that free or individual licenses lack.
The Challenge of AI Note-Taking: Insight vs. Integrity
One of the most powerful and complex applications of AI is in meeting transcription and note-taking. AI tools can automatically create searchable transcripts and summaries of your meetings, offering unprecedented insights into key discussions and action items. For nonprofits, this can be invaluable for board meetings, strategic planning sessions, or internal team debriefs.
However, these tools also create a new type of data—large volumes of potentially sensitive information stored as digital files. The user is left to decide where to save these transcripts, what permissions to assign them, and how long to retain them. This raises critical questions about data retention and cybersecurity risks. Is that transcript of a confidential meeting sitting in an unsecured folder? What is the tool’s privacy policy for that data?
This is where a strategic approach to technology is vital. By selecting an AI note-taking tool that integrates with your managed IT infrastructure, an administrator can set a data retention policy. You can configure the system to automatically delete transcripts after a pre-determined period, such as 30, 60, or 90 days. This practice helps you follow a clear data governance strategy, prevents the accumulation of unnecessary files, and mitigates the risk of sensitive information becoming public. You gain the valuable insights from your meetings while protecting the integrity of your organization.
A Strategic Partnership for a Secure Future
AI technology is not a fleeting trend; it is the next evolution in how we work. For nonprofits, the question is not whether to use AI, but how to do so responsibly and effectively. Using free AI tools at nonprofits is an increasing risk. A partnership with a managed service provider like Community IT Innovators helps your organization make the transition from reactive, ad-hoc technology use to a proactive, strategic approach.
We can help you vet and select the right AI tools, negotiate cost-effective enterprise licenses, and implement robust cybersecurity measures. By placing AI under the guidance of an administrator and focusing on structured training and demos, you empower your staff to leverage these powerful tools for their mission while protecting your organization’s most valuable assets: your data, your reputation, and your ability to fulfill your mission.
Ready to get strategic about your IT?
Community IT has been serving nonprofits exclusively for almost twenty-five years. We offer Managed IT support services for nonprofits that want to outsource all or part of their IT support and hosted services. For a fixed monthly fee, we provide unlimited remote and on-site help desk support, proactive network management, and ongoing IT planning from a dedicated team of experts in nonprofit-focused IT. And our clients benefit from our IT Business Managers team who will work with you to plan your IT investments and technology roadmap if you don’t have an in-house IT Director.
We constantly research and evaluate new technology to ensure that you get cutting-edge solutions that are tailored to your organization, using standard industry tech tools that don’t lock you into a single vendor or consultant. And we don’t treat any aspect of nonprofit IT as if it is too complicated for you to understand. We know that free AI tools at Nonprofits aren’t always a good thing.
We think your IT vendor should be able to explain everything without jargon or lingo. If you can’t understand your IT management strategy to your own satisfaction, keep asking your questions until you find an outsourced IT provider who will partner with you for well-managed IT.
If you’re ready to gain peace of mind about your IT support, let’s talk.
As advocates for using technology to work smarter, we’re practicing what we recommend. This article was drafted with the assistance of an AI, but the content was reviewed, edited, and finalized by a human editor to ensure accuracy and relevance.
Photo by ThisisEngineering on Unsplash